What’s next? Thoughts on Education, Employment, And A.i.

Many describe college as the best years of their lives, which is a hilariously daunting sentiment as a current student. After hearing the same fantastic stories of late night shenanigans, struggle meals, then subsequent melancholic descriptor, that conversation always leaves you with the same lingering question: “What’s next?” 

After graduating, all students face the uncomfortably large task of structuring their life without the guidance and sense of belonging that college offers. What was once an exciting rite of passage and a tantalizing confrontation of the unknown is now a terrifying economic awakening. It is paralyzing trying to pick a direction that could ultimately define the trajectory of your life. Today, the choice is ever more insurmountable thanks to inflation. Inflation of marketable skills, technology, the economy, the quality of education, and even the value of a degree.

Traditionally, higher education has been the greatest stepping stone in the systemic pipeline to what most define as success. While there are equally respected and alternative ways to achieve class comfort, and even more alternative lifestyles to pursue, higher education was always the tried and true and culturally typical way to course one’s life. But, in response to the rapid and unpredictable changes to the economy and job market because of generative artificial intelligence, students are now finding that 4 years of college doesn’t get you as far as it used to. Which is completely unjust and frustrating considering the price of education has skyrocketed while the quality has plummeted. But why now? Why our generation? Is it even possible to pinpoint a cause, then predict a trajectory?

Humans have an intrinsic way of following the path of least resistance. This probably comes from a natural instinct to survive; we create systems of efficacy that allow us to not work as hard. Thus explaining why the industrial revolution was such a pinnacle of human success, why people use A.I. to write their class discussions, why people are addicted to drugs, why people would rather spend hours scrolling on social media instead of reading, and finally, why we choose to consume rather than create; because it’s easier to accept that something is difficult than to actually do it. 

Language learning models have been incredibly successful at capitalizing on this inclination, and if left unchecked can, to put bluntly, completely hijack our ability to think critically and create. This is not speculation anymore; it’s empirically proven. One National Institutes of Health study even calls A.I. in education a “cognitive paradox”. America has seen lowered success rates in math and literacy in the last 6 years, and while this can largely be credited to the 2020 pandemic learning curve, there has been little to no recovery since. Consequently, higher education has entered a feedback loop of simplifying curriculum to cater to declining participation and success rates. The adoption of A.I. in most academic settings is deluded and advertised as a streamlined performance tool, simplifying tasks like research and notetaking– but in actuality, there is no way in which generative A.I. can be used that does not augment the negative effects of outsourcing cognitive labor. 

This poses a new threat to employers and recent graduates who are entering the workforce: education is too easy. Recent cultural trends show that students who graduate with just a B.A. degree are entering the workforce unequipped with the proper skill sets needed to succeed. Employers are realizing just how easy it is to slide through an undergraduate college degree, which is why you may have heard the phrase: “A Master’s is the new Bachelor’s.” The recent graduates who are sitting in the interview seats are underqualified, undereducated, and lack cognitive vigor.  

What is more troubling than the declining value of human creation is how enthusiastic we are supposed to be about it. I recently received a promotional email from Canvas with the subject line “Creating has never been easier”, advertising their latest generative A.I. tool, and I almost flipped the table. Words used to describe A.I. like “accessible”, “productive” or “revolutionary” are veneers; marketing strategies that make the user think they are making the smarter and more efficient choice by using A.I. to do a task for you. This completely forgives the mental guilt of using generative A.I. instead of your brain for educational intents and purposes.

But that’s just one piece of the puzzle. It’s not the case that students just need to work harder; it is that students can’t compete with A.I. in the workforce anyway. Disregarding the plethora of negative impacts A.I. has on academia, generative A.I. has completely metamorphosed the workforce landscape. The rapid changes in workforce demands because of A.I. have outsized certain degrees, leaving students stranded. Careers in clerical work, translation, data processing, and much more are all threatened by a hallucinating, half-baked software that can do a subpar rendition of these tasks for free. To the multi-billion dollar industries and businesses, outsourcing human labor with A.I. is like dangling tri-tip in front of a hungry bear. When students graduate, they are not just facing unemployment; they’re facing unachievable levels of output, competing with manufactured marketable skills, and repositioning themselves constantly to try and outperform everchanging workforce needs.  

While this all seems overwhelmingly minatory, I’ll leave the reader with this idea: the world has always followed cyclical trends of ages of enlightenment and of devastation. While inflation (in the broadest sense) has stuck its tongue in every crevasse of culture and society, dampened the world with ignorance, stripped us of creativity, and crumpled morals and humanity into a ball– there emerges a pedestal for the thinkers, the artists, and the creators to claim. 

When the majority of jobs have become automated and streamlined, and we are permitted to simply pick up the scraps that capitalism and technology have thrown to us, there is an opportunity for those who manage to avoid letting technology think for us to claim whatever path we so choose. Because when everything is taken from us, we have nothing to lose.

-Josephine Fahey