Santa Cruz: The Black Experience

, ,

There is currently a 1% Black student population at Cabrillo College, which appropriately reflects the 1.6% population in the whole of Santa Cruz County. In an area that prides itself on progressive tolerance and claims to be accepting, why is the Black population so low?

In recent years, it seems as though many have been reexamining racial biases on a personal and institutional level, and few have been brave enough to reveal the racist underbelly of Santa Cruz and Cabrillo College.

There is a high level of conviction that the Santa Cruz County and Cabrillo communities hold regarding their level of cultural competence. Given the communities’ avowed forward ideals, do Black people in these communities agree? 

In 2019, I moved from Oakland to Santa Cruz, California. Navigating my first year of high school in a new area was my biggest worry until I was confronted with the absurdities of being one of the very few black-identified students at my school and an even more alarming amount of ignorance, bigotry, and tolerance.

I am mixed-race, with Ethiopian and American heritage. Growing up in Oakland and being surrounded by Ethiopian and Black culture, belonging and cultural safety was never something I thought I would have to cherish, especially in the academic realm.

It was a stark change, and grossly unnerving. In Oakland, a Black presence on campus was the norm; In an Aptos High School passing period, the n-word was tossed around by white and Latine kids like a ball at play.

Upon my displacement, I found myself to be the target of ignorant racial biases from both instructors and students. I learned quickly that the amount of acceptance my school had was incorrectly self-proclaimed and never backed by action or words. And this sentiment translates well to the community overall. 

Maleah Benjamin, a 21-year-old medical assistant major here at Cabrillo, shared her experiences as a mixed-race African-American and Filipino living in Watsonville. 

Benjamin has lived in Santa Cruz County for 19 years. In elementary school, she faced similar struggles and had to deal with bigotry regularly. Students would make insensitive racial jokes at her expense and call her names.

“I grew up being like one of, maybe two if I’m lucky, usually just the one black girl in my school,” Benjamin says. 

Benjamin recalled a time in elementary school when a classmate made a racist joke, to which she used physical violence as a response. As Benjamin grew older, she learned to use humor or sarcasm to negate it, but she questions why she has to experience racism in the first place.

“Why is that the case? Why aren’t they knowing better from home? And that’s what scares me, honestly.”

Benjamin says she identified more with her Filipino heritage due to the outstanding community in Watsonville. But as a black-presenting individual, it was hard to find belonging.

“It was hard to figure out where I fit, which ultimately came down to nowhere.”

In a 2018 focus group study by the Community College Equity Assessment Lab (CCEAL), it was found that “African American students did not feel a sense of belonging at Cabrillo and reported experiencing racial microaggressions on an ongoing basis—both on campus and in the Aptos community.”

Despite the adversity she faced in her adolescence, Benjamin was impressed by the warmth of Cabrillo, specifically the Equity Department. She says Devin Walker, Dean of Student Equity, and Alta Cilicia Northcutt, Director of Student Life and the Umoja Program, were leading agents of her scholastic success. But the outreach Cabrillo currently provides to Black students was a struggle to achieve.

Northcutt commented on the difficulty of maintaining a black-centered program before Umoja arrived at Cabrillo. Northcutt said fluctuating enrollment rates and participation of black-identified students prevented the long-term establishment of Black student interest groups. Additionally, students felt discouraged because of the national scrutiny of being black during the crux of the Black Lives Matter movement in 2020.

After the political climate calmed, there was a surge of students eager to reclaim the community they had lost. Unfortunately, there was heavy objection by certain members of the Cabrillo administration. Despite the demur, the Black constituents of Cabrillo persisted and established the successful and ever-growing Umoja program. 

The Cabrillo administration and board are notoriously understood as tenets of the deep-rooted institutional racism of Cabrillo. I wish it could be said that all leaders of our institution are catalysts of change or embody the College’s Mission statement, but that would be a falsehood.

During a recent Governing Board meeting, a board member made a highly insensitive comment towards a Black staff member, ironically, during a resolution discussion for the continuance of support for Black History Month.

The trustee expressed their disapproval of a racist post made by President Trump, depicting Former President Barack and Former First Lady Michelle Obama as monkeys. The Trustee then singled out a Black administrator, saying the post reminded them of said administrator, and asked the target if they had any comments regarding the post. 

The comment was highly problematic and not the first time the board has proved its racial ineptitude. The comment not only targeted and ostracized the administrator and the three other Black individuals in the room, but also publicly exposed the trustee’s racial biases and personal ruminations. 

Among the emotional burdens of being Black in Santa Cruz County, the community suffers a disproportionate amount of inequalities compared to other racial identity groups, and this is statistically proven by persistent equity gaps in education, finance, housing, and food security.

According to Cabrillo College’s Student Equity and Achievement statistics (SEA Plan), there is a consistent 10% equity gap in success and completion between minoritized and majoritized students. In Fall 2025, Black students had a 65% course success rate (finished courses with a C or higher).

Additionally, in a #RealCollege California Basic Needs Climate survey in spring 2023, 89.09% of Black Cabrillo students experienced housing insecurity, compared to 55.48% overall, and 56.6% of students self-identified as homeless, compared to 22.61% overall. In the same study, 85.45% of Black Cabrillo students experienced food insecurity compared to 52.02% overall, and 60% of Black students said they didn’t eat for a whole day because they couldn’t afford food. 

Despite the prevalent obstacles that the Black community faces, there are pockets of joy and a shared sense of resilience. Among the students that I interviewed, the Umoja Program and community are large contributors to their sense of belonging. 

Jordan Simpkins, a 21-year-old African American, health science major, and Cabrillo athlete, says that she didn’t get involved with Umoja until her second year at Cabrillo.

“I was a little lonely. Like, ‘where are the people I can make jokes and laugh with?’” 

Originally from South Carolina and Mississippi, Simpkins noted the struggles of moving to a predominantly white area. She specifically noted how hard it was to make Black friends outside of school and the difficulty of not having black hair specialists in her area. 

Simpkins explained that upon joining Umoja, she felt more “at home.”  

“Umoja has put that emptiness away and filled my heart…” says Simpkins. 

Chidinma Kalu, a first-year Nigerian student studying business at Cabrillo, shares a similar sentiment. She feels especially welcomed by Umoja and the staff in the Multicultural Student Center.

Kalu moved to Scotts Valley three years ago and has appreciated the overall diversity of Santa Cruz, but being the only Black person in a room can make her feel “like one of many.” She often commented that she’s not easily bothered by the benign racial biases of others, partly because of her internal confidence, but also her educational goals and ability to self-advocate.

Particularly interested in dance, Kalu was disappointed in the lack of diversity provided by the Cabrillo dance program.

“I wanted to join the dance classes and realized the styles I wanted to do were kind of watered down.”

Kalu emphasized that that was her only grievance, and otherwise feels very seen and supported by the Cabrillo community. She explains that Umoja has been a wonderful resource and has greatly helped her integrate herself as a Black student. 

She says, “It’s very rare, you mostly walk around just braving it and just not caring, but then you meet the people, and you’re like ‘Oh my goodness!’”

The isolation and quiet sadness that Kalu and Simpkins described are felt throughout the Black community here in Santa Cruz. The uniqueness of adversity makes it even harder to share.

Instances of bigotry, such as singling out Black voices or self-proclaiming righteousness, may not come from malicious intent but accomplish the same amount of harm as explicit racism and, moreover, create an atmosphere that excludes black authenticity. It is an invisible burden that Black people shoulder.

Programs with the overarching goal of Black excellence and joy are a tribute to the resilience of the community. Umoja, Black Surf Santa Cruz, and Santa Cruz Black , among others, are what bring an otherwise separated community together. Despite the inordinate labors of simply existing as a Black individual, the strength and richness of culture permeates regardless. 

Josephine Fahey

Leave a Reply